Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Most Dangerous Division in Sports

Was Dan Henderson's Victory Over Fedor Emelianenko Tainted by TRT?

via cdn0.sbnation.com

Late last week I wrote that I believed Dan Henderson's legacy had the most to gain from his fight with Fedor Emelianenko and despite the controversial stoppage (I personally agreed with it)  I stand with my assessment.  The two looked evenly matched through the opening minutes, with Henderson having more success initially in the clinch before he was dropped by the former Pride FC heavyweight champion.  Henderson's sweep and subsequent knockout was his fourth statement finish in the last five times he's stepped into the cage, and it would seem that Dan's buzz is back to an all-time high.

I can say without hesitation that I am a Dan Henderson fan.  That being said, I can't help but think that the fact he is competing at such a high level at a relatively old age is compromised by his use of TRT- Testosterone Replacement Therapy.  Keith Kizer has described in the past the methods used to investigate to some degree of certainty whether a fighter's low testosterone levels are due to prior steroid use- LH (Luteinizing hormone/lutropin) and FSH (follicle-stimulating hormone) levels are checked with testosterone levels, and if these hormones are also considered to be at a lower than normal level it might indicate possible past steroid use.

I cannot say that I have ever heard of TRT being used in sport outside of Mixed Martial Arts, and in a way that's perplexing.  I recognize that the brutal intensity of the workouts is taxing on one's body but in my mind there is something awry with the physique of the main three names associated with the therapy- Chael Sonnen, Nate Marquardt, and Henderson. I certainly recognize that physique is not proof of "performance enhancement," but it seems far-fetched that a person with low levels of testosterone in the prime of their athletic career looks like any of that bunch.  

In no way am I implying Dan has used any of the substances that are nowadays associated with performance enhancement.  With his age rapidly approaching forty-one and no positive tests in his career, it would be foolish and completely disrespectful to suggest the MMA great has been anything but honest in his career. That being said, is the relative lack of this medical therapy's method in major sports any indication of a strange exception to the drug testing rules?

Star-divide

If we examine the uses of steroids, human growth hormone (HGH), and similar substances throughout the major sports we see that as often as these drugs are taken in the context of strength building and performance improvement, they are in injury rehabilitation- and yet there is a definitive double standard in TRT or any similar exception.  At Henderson's age, would the added testosterone give him any advantage in healing compared to another athlete?  Have their been any other examples of an athlete in one of the major sports utilizing such an exemption to prolong their career? The brief research I did would indicate no. So should all other competitors be tested for hormonal levels so that they may be able to regulate their own?  I realize that this question sounds a bit ridiculous, but truthfully what other baseline could we possibly use to substantiate such a small percentage of fighters being approved for a TUE- Therapeutic Use Exemption?

Henderson himself has called for regular drug testing for all Mixed Martial Artists, and that is admirable of him. To some degree it eliminates any shred of doubt that Dan is using Testosterone Replacement in a manner that is consistent with its intent. I, for one, see little difference between someone thats hormone levels have diminished over time versus someone who is having trouble rehabbing from nagging and lingering injuries.  I choose neither side in allowing the substances in the sport, but as a fan I demand consistency.  If we are allowing some athletes to utilize exceptions for substances that would be banned to the majority of their competition, I want to know that every single person has been tested for such a deficiency.  

Was Dan Henderson's victory over Fedor Emelianenko tainted by TRT?  In my opinion, no.  If Dan is being tested in a consistent manner to his competitors, and passing all the necessary tests, he should be allowed to compete.  The recent career ascension he's undergone well past the normal age of a fighter's retirement is nothing short of Randy Couture-esque.  I do believe that something is tainted, however- this sport's drug policy.  As I said: as a fan of MMA and of all sports, I demand consistency.  And right now I think MMA is anything but consistent with its relationship to "performance enhancers."

Comment 8 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

I'm glad Dan won...

But, I thought about this after the fight. I thought “I wonder if Fedor’s decline is due to him not taking ‘things’(as opposed to Dan)?”.

"BE is the Fox News of MMA sites." - Teh Interwebz

Cageside Seats Sux- FloydSR

by FloydJoyMayweatherSR on Aug 3, 2011 2:14 AM EDT reply actions  

Good post! It’s definitely a complicated issue.. to me it seems a bit fishy that guys in their 40’s are going to keep competing at the highest level, with the use of TRT and the like. I mean, it’s pretty normal that your performance drops once you reach those age number. To me it’s pretty much guaranteed that Randy Couture was on something too.. I don’t know, in a way it makes sense to fix your levels if they’re getting lower, but at the same time maybe you shouldn’t do it to be able to compete. It’s just not natural.

by Horselover Fat on Aug 3, 2011 5:08 AM EDT reply actions  

I see things in black and white when it comes to TUE’s; if you’ve been able to compete without a TUE you shouldn’t be getting one 10 years after making your debut. Whether the lowered testosterone (or whatever) levels are a result of previous steroid use or just a natural result of aging, it still goes against the idea of competing when you artificially boost your numbers.

No athletes are born equal; some are faster, some are stronger, some are more agile. Sports are the most fascinating (to me) when eg. the weaker guy outfoxes the stronger guy by being faster or applying technique. The beauty of having older guys like Randy Couture performing at the highest level is that they use their experience to make up for their decreasing physical features.

If the playing field is “levelled” by slowing the natural regression of physical characteristics, you create fewer outliers as more 40+ year olds will be able to perform at the highest level, and isn’t one of the greatest things about having Hendo’s and Couture’s that we can marvel at their ability to outsmart and outperform younger, stronger, faster opponents?

All that being said, I really can’t fault Hendo for playing by the rules. I agree with the author that the sport’s drug policy is more at fault than any individual.

by wonderfulspam on Aug 3, 2011 9:02 AM EDT reply actions  

Since this was the only article I've found that mentioned this post-Saturday,

I’m guessing the answer is no. As long as he doesn’t ever test out of range, this will get swept under the rug and no one will care. Seems to be the case, remember the Shane Carwin story? Oh, not until you read this post just now?

by Machiel Van on Aug 3, 2011 12:34 PM EDT reply actions  

nope

http://mixedmartialartsblogger.wordpress.com/

Mel Gibson shot the movie Apocalypto on location at the center of my taint.
-Fake Emcee

by Cory Braiterman on Aug 3, 2011 3:38 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

FanPosts

Recent Posts


Managers

Strangesuspense_small Rainer Lee

Editors

Lightbulb-orange_bigger_small David Castillo

Lebowski_excited_grin_small Cory Braiterman

Authors

Princeton_shield_small Anthony Pace

Kari_sweets_2_small ElliotMatheny

Doggylets_small Chris Hall

Small Patrick Wyman

408031_10151137119550462_571520461_22348230_944591543_n_small Chad Raynard

Monocle_man_small Earl Montclair

5cyt7k_small Jack Slack